CO129-231 - Acting Governor Marsh - 1887 [1-3] — Page 107

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

We must remember that food prison is like pay to a mercenary, every interference with custom or supposed rights, is liable to end in mutiny. It will be necessary therefore to take every precaution to avoid various disturbance and bloodshed, — particularly considering that most of the prisoners live in association, and have every opportunity of secretly conspiring.

I have, as is my duty in my position, carefully considered what is the best course for me to adopt in every contingency that can happen in Gaol: In case of a riot owing to reduction of food, or any other cause of discontent where the sympathies of all the prisoners would be with the rioters, prompt action, and the instant punishment of the ringleader, appears to me the best and most merciful course. Firing into the mob of rioters is the simplest and most efficacious of these measures; no unarmed mob will stand firearms. On the other hand, more humane measures should be adopted if possible.

The manner in which I should wish to meet an outbreak of violence would be, instantly to seize the ringleaders, march them to the office, try them, and award corporal punishment, a step which in my opinion would intimidate the rest.

Edit History

2026-05-25 11:33:27 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
We must remember that food prison is like pay to a mercenary, every interference with custom or supposed rights, is liable to end in mutiny. It will be necessary therefore to take every precaution to avoid various disturbance and bloodshed, particularly considering that most of the prisoners live in association, and have every opportunity of secretly conspiring. I have, as is my duty in my position, carefully considered what is the best course for me to adopt in every contingency that can happen in Gaol: In case of a riot owing to reduction of food, or any other cause of discontent where the sympathies of all the prisoners would be with the rioters, prompt action, and the instant punishment of the ringleader, appears to me the best and most merciful course. Firing into the mob of rioters is the simplest and most efficacious of these measures; no unarmed mob will stand firearms. On the other hand, more humane measures should be adopted if possible. The manner in which I should wish to meet an outbreak of violence would be, instantly to seize the ringleaders, march them to the office, try them, and award corporal punishment, a step which in my opinion would intimidate the rest.
Baseline (Original)
! Q We must remember that food prismen is like pay to a Wercenary, every interference to with custom or supposed nights, is liable to end in meeting. will the r necessary If to take themefore be every precaution to avoid verions disturbance and bloodshed, bloodshed, particularly considering most of the that prisoners live in association, and have every opportunity of secretly conspiring. I have, as is my duty in my position, carefully considered what is the best couvise for me to adopt in every contingency that the Can cae e happen in Gaol : In of a riot owing to reduction of food, or any other cause discontent where the ause of sympathies of all the prisoner would be with the riders, prompt cation, and the instant punishment. of 106 of the ringleader, appears to me the best and most merciful Firing course. into the mob of rioters in the simplest and most efficacions of these ureaus ; no unarmed mob will stand firearms. Back on the other hand, more more humane me amin should be adopted if possible The manner in which I should wish to meet an outbreak. on autbreak of violence would be, inskently to seize the ringleaders, march them to the them, and awa office, try corporal punishment, a stop which in my opcicion woul intimidate the rest. X X
2026-05-25 11:33:27 · Baseline
View content

!

Q

We must remember that food prismen is like pay to a Wercenary, every interference

to

with custom or supposed nights,

is liable to end in meeting.

will the

r

necessary

If

to take

themefore be every precaution to avoid verions disturbance and bloodshed,

bloodshed, —

particularly considering

most of

the

that

prisoners live in

association, and have every

opportunity of secretly conspiring.

I have,

as is my duty in

my position, carefully considered

what is the best couvise

for

me

to adopt in every contingency

that

the

Can

cae e

happen in Gaol : In

of a riot owing to reduction

of food, or any

other cause

discontent where the

ause of

sympathies

of all the prisoner would be with the riders, prompt cation, and the instant punishment.

of

106

of the ringleader, appears to me the best and most merciful

Firing

course.

into the mob of rioters in the simplest and most efficacions of these ureaus ; no unarmed mob will stand firearms. Back on the other hand, more

more humane me amin should be adopted if possible

The

manner in which I should wish to meet an outbreak.

on

autbreak of violence

would be, inskently to seize the

ringleaders, march them to the

them, and awa

office, try

corporal punishment, a stop which in my opcicion woul

intimidate the rest.

X

X

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.